The Enlightenment brought forward many philosophers who paved the way for the “modernization” of the West. These philosophers questioned the existence of God, a central theme in many of their writings, as manifested by famous quotes—such as “God is dead”—that many still cite. Following their work, one finds that today’s writings, which continue to argue against the existence of God, have not proposed anything new. In fact, the pagans of Quraysh used the same arguments used by what we call now as “Atheists”. The only difference between Quraysh and today’s Atheists is that the latter cover their accusations with what I like to call scientific clothing, giving their arguments a sense of sanctity that many feel reluctant to argue against.
When the Prophet Muhammad began preaching the message of the Quran in Mecca, the pagans of Quraysh accused both the Prophet and the message revealed in the Quran as being “legends of the former people which he has written down” (25:5). Stated differently, Quraysh accused the Quran of reviving old legends that had been passed down from generation to generation. Quraysh claimed that they were too “progressive” and technologically advanced to believe in these so-called bedtime stories.
Now compare their assertions to modern claims about the existence of God. Of course, the major difference between the two is that such accusations are being spearheaded by “scholars” who use the banner of science and reason to give their disbelief a sense of legitimacy. They claim that God does not exist and work to prove this. As a matter of fact, anyone with a little understanding of modern science knows that those involved scientific research conduct experiments in three main steps: they (1) develop a theory, (2) test the theory, and (3) verify the tests and make conclusions. Many tests can be verified for a few hundreds of years before they are falsified by a new theory. Thus, it suffices to say that science does not always provide us with absolute truths.
Another example of the claims made against the existence of God even before the advent of Islam was Pharaoh’s claim to Musa that “There is not but our first death, and we will not be resurrected. Then bring [back] our forefathers, if you should be truthful” (44:35-36). Here, Pharaoh is astonished by the fact that there will be a resurrection after death. He then challenges Musa, as the verses clearly display, to resurrect the dead. Atheists in the modern age are also baffled by the idea that a human could be resurrected after death.
Ever since the Enlightenment, most of the Western civilization went through a so-called “reformation”, in which religion was disregarded and science replaced the notion of the sacred. This naturally paved the way for the emphasis on the material world and disregard to the metaphysical one. In other words, to many Western scientists, anything that cannot be empirically verified does not exist. By that logic, there can never be an empirical experiment that proves or disproves the concept of life after death, or even a life that exists beyond this material world, so many of them would reject the notion of life after death.
Modern atheists extend their beliefs about resurrection by asserting that our lives end the day we die. The Quran describes non-believers as saying, “Does he promise you that when you have died and become dust and bones that you will be brought forth [once more]? How far, how far, is that which you are promised. Life is not but our worldly life—we die and live, but we will not be resurrected.” The notion that non-believers ridicule the idea of a Day of Judgment has been a long-standing topic in each of the Prophet’s stories in the Quran. While modern atheists believe that they are coming up with infallible ideas, the Quran addressed these topics some 1,400 years ago.
These claims could have many implications for the lives of humans. First, it gives humans who lack the inclination to do good a sense of comfort, because they believe that they will never be questioned about their deeds. Even though many atheists would claim that people can do good without God, which could be true, this is not enough. Not everyone is willing to do good or, at least, to stay away from doing evil. Once a person is conscious that death is not the end and that they will be resurrected, rewarded and punished depending on their deeds, they might be able to better control their actions. Second, firmly believing that our lives end the day we die aggravates the human tendency to become selfish. This is because if we do not believe that there will be an afterlife during which we will reap our harvest, we will focus on maximizing our utility in this life, even if it comes at the expense of others. Third, human beings are spiritual creatures. They find it very difficult to live without constantly engaging their spiritual side in prayer or some kind of connection with the metaphysical world. Once they lose their spiritual side, they will find it very difficult to live a life of content and fulfillment. This is one of the reasons why the modern human beings, though having achieved their most advanced state of technological and scientific development, have been struggling more than ever with depression and mental health issues.